Pretty Little Liars Re-Cap: Mid-Season Finale - 'The Lady Killer'
The other Liars, meanwhile, receive an anonymous text, asking them to meet at Alison’s (now empty) grave. Hannah brings Caleb and Caleb brings a gun. When no one comes to meet them, they decide Paige must be after Emily. Knowing that she can only be at one of two Lighthouse Rock Inns, they split up - the Liars to one, and Caleb and his secret weapon (literally) to the other.
At the cabin, Emily gets a spooky anonymous phone call, saying, “You have one minute. Get out now.” She’s relieved to see Nate, but not for long.
She notices paint on Nate’s shoe, and remembers a paint-covered sneaker in a picture of Maya at Tru North. While I try and figure out why Nate hasn’t bought new shoes yet, Emily realizes that Nate is not who he says he is. He must be the stalker Maya told her about from Tru North!
After Emily unsuccessfully tries to escape, Nate (really Lyndon James) explains that he loved Maya and that’s why he killed her. He thought that Emily could replace Maya’s love, but (duh!) Emily’s a lesbian and chose Paige instead. Not-Nate then says, “I am gonna do to you what you did to me. I am going to take something from you, and you are going to watch me do it,” and he reveals a petrified Paige tied up (ironically) in the closet.
More on next page...